Story · Ajahn Brahm
The retreat cook on work release
Content note: sexual violence (multiple rape) mentioned; named private ex-offender (first name) — do not publish identification; safety framing needed
The story — as told by Ajahn Brahm (verbatim captions)
We were teaching a retreat many years ago and we couldn't find a we couldn't find a uh a cook for the retreat. So I managed to to grab this guy to do the the cooking for us. And he was brilliant cook. He did it all by himself and he did a wonderful job. And at the end of the retreat when we start to thank people, he disappeared. He'd gone. They said, "Where's Carl? We want to say say thank you to him." And so he's back in kind of prison farm now. He was on work release. And I told people then that Carl was in prison for multiple rape. And straight away people said, "I jump on. You mean you let a multiple rapist come and cook for us for 9 days? Isn't that dangerous? I said, "No, look, I know him. He wouldn't hurt the fly. He never did. He did those crimes when he was uh young and involved in drugs. He wouldn't do anything now. He never did. But the main purpose of not telling them first of all and telling at the very end was to say just how How unfairly do we judge people? He's changed. He's uh paid for his crimes. Maybe not paid. I'm not sure. But he's certainly just leaving him in jail to rot is not going to help anybody. But let him come out. He's I think he's Where is he working now? He's got married to a nice uh girl now. And I think he's working. He's in the northern suburbs somewhere. Osman Park. No, not Osman Park, but somewhere around that area. Really nice guy.
▶ Watch Ajahn Brahm tell it from 1:11:05 (to 1:13:02)
A reflection (in the spirit of Ajahn Brahm's talk)
The brilliant retreat cook was on work release from prison for a very serious crime committed when young, and has since rebuilt his life. Ajahn Brahm told the retreatants only afterwards, to ask how quickly we define people by their worst act. Safety matters. So does believing people can change, ourselves included.
In brief (our summary)
Without a cook for a nine-day retreat at Jhana Grove, Ajahn Brahm finds Carl, a brilliant cook who does everything alone. At the closing thanks he has gone — back to the prison farm; he was on work release. Only then does Ajahn Brahm tell the retreatants Carl was in prison for multiple rape, committed when young and on drugs. Shocked — 'isn't that dangerous?' — they're asked how unfairly we judge people. Carl has since married and works in the northern suburbs.
Teaching point
Don't define people by the worst things they did; they can change.
When this story may help
- ex-offenders
- second chances
- judging others
Themes
Source & credit
Told by Ajahn Brahm in Our Mind and Our Health | Ajahn Brahm | 7 July 2023 · 2023-07-08 · ▶ watch from 1:11:05 to 1:13:02 · Buddhist Society of Western Australia
6 other tellings of this story
- How to be Free | Ajahn Brahm | 26 November 2021 · 2021-11-26 · ▶ watch from 46:13 to 50:36 · Buddhist Society of Western AustraliaNov 2021 telling: he admits it didn't go through the BSWA committee; the cook makes vegetarian pizzas from scratch for 60–70 people; the cook agreed to Ajahn Brahm telling the retreatants roughly what he had done (convicted of rape several times). The cook is unnamed here.
- Having Positive Attitudes towards Everybody | Ajahn Brahm | 12 March 2021 · 2021-03-12 · ▶ watch from 15:08 to 18:09 · Buddhist Society of Western Australia2021 telling: the prisoner (unnamed here) from Karnet Prison Farm already did work at the monastery; the guards agreed; 60 retreatants; home-made pizzas from the flour up; 'in jail for a violent rape'; 'I could respect his pizzas and open the door of my mouth to them'.
- Kindness Creates Peace | Ajahn Brahm | 18 February 2022 · 2022-02-18 · ▶ watch from 37:21 to 39:37 · Buddhist Society of Western AustraliaFeb 2022 telling: reminded by Donna (ex-psych at Karnet); Jhana Grove ('Janagra'); pizzas from flour; prison truck each day; named only as rape (drugs); now married and well. Do not publish identification.
- Freedom | Ajahn Brahm | 5 July 2024 · 2024-07-06 · ▶ watch from 39:09 to 39:50 · Buddhist Society of Western AustraliaJul 2024 telling: Carl amazing Jhana Grove cook on work release for rape; retreat goes quiet — person who did a rape, not 'a rapist'.
- New Year's Eve with Ajahn Brahm | 31 December 2024 · 2025-01-01 · ▶ watch from 27:24 to 30:40 · Buddhist Society of Western AustraliaNYE 2024: 9-day cook vanishes at thanks — Karnet work release; young rape conviction; audience shock then forgive.
- Understanding is more important - Armadale Meditation Group | Ajahn Brahm | 1 November 2022 · 2022-11-03 · ▶ watch from 1:22:29 to 1:23:32 · Buddhist Society of Western AustraliaArmadale: Carl cook from Cardinal/Karnet prison farm — thanks after retreat.
Caption notes: YouTube auto-captions: unpunctuated, words left exactly as captioned. 'Janna Grove' = Jhana Grove (not changed).
The narrative is Ajahn Brahm's own telling, quoted from the talk captions. The summary and reflection are Being Mindful Stories's editorial notes. Please credit the teacher and link the original talk. Markdown version